Posted by: movieotaku | April 10, 2007

Black Holes and Quantum Singularities

Offenders: Lots of shows, but mostly Star Trek: Voyager

Black Holes are interesting phenomena. They are the closest thing we can get to oblivion in the Universe. There are far too many examples of abusing black hole theory to list, but I can address several of the more popular ones.

Black Holes lead to another place in space-time, maybe another Universe

This was a theory for awhile, but it sort of fell apart as people did the math. A Black Hole made of ordinary matter almost certainly leads nowhere but the singularity. See the Black Hole FAQ for details.

You can punch a hole in the event horizon to escape

This was the second or third episode of Star Trek: Voyager where we see the Voyager get trapped inside a “quantum singularity” which has an “event horizon”. Sounds like a Black Hole to me. The writer, one Brannon Braga, decided the event horizon was a force field that could be punched through. Nuh-uh. The event horizon is more of an imaginary line, like the equator. It’s the point where time and space warps so extremely that once you slip past the event horizon, you can’t ever escape.



  1. Actually, you cannot escape from inside an event horizon if you’re restricted to moving slower than the speed of light. If you can move faster than the speed of light (as Voyager is supposed to) then you would have no problems escaping a black hole.

  2. Of course, Janeway gives the order for “Max impulse drive!” in the episode… So they’re not using the space-time warping drive that WOULD allow them to escape.

  3. i do not remember the particular episode… but if you were to have a device capable of producing gravitons…as im sure the voyager does (i know they have used the deflector array to do this at least once) then you could easily create a “hole” in the event horizon by generating a gravitational dampening field….

    and max impulse gets close enough to light speed… i think 3/4 of c that you wouldnt need too much of a dampening field (in the terms of a space-time warping starship) to do so.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: